Thursday, July 26, 2012

In "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings", what is the symbolic meaning of the old man?

Your question seems to raise a much larger issue about how
we as readers interpret and assign symbols to objects and characters in our often futile
attempts to make meaning of what we read.


I think one of
the joys of this short story is that it defies interpretation. You need to note how the
villagers are often exposed as foolish and gullible in their beliefs, and also how they
try to make sense of the world. They stick fast to "facts" even though they are clearly
ridiculous, such as the fact that angels eat mothballs, and they jump to impossible
conclusions, for example when some argue that the old man should be proclaimed "mayor of
the world." It is almost as if once they have conceived of an idea they make reality
"fit" to support that idea despite any protestations to the contrary - or until a
"better" version of the "truth" comes along and then the process beings again. Of
course, the villagers, although they can be said to be figures of fun in this sense,
contain many characteristics which we can identify whatever our time or culture - for
example the unquestioning belief in their own wisdom and their stubborn clinging to
their own ideas are aspects which we can all identify.


It
is clear though that while there are a few hints into this story as to the "meaning" or
"allegory" there are no conclusive pointers that give one definitive explanation. We are
left, much like the villagers therefore, to try and make some sort of meaning from these
strange and bizarre events. The last laugh seems to be with Marquez, however, as we
prove ourselves to be like the villagers trying to make sense of this story and coming
up with very different and ridiculous answers. Therefore, if there is a "meaning", it is
that there is no "meaning" - it is more about the process by which we make "meaning" and
how we support our conclusions.


So I am not going to answer
your question, as I think if you do try to summarise the angel's symbolic significance
you are falling into precisely the kind of trap that Marquez wants you to fall
into!

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment on the setting and character of "The Fall of the House of Usher."How does setting act as a character?

Excellent observation, as it identifies how the settings of Poe's stories reflect the characters of their protagonists. Whet...