A journal is usually a personal written response to
something. You can write a daily journal recording your daily experiences, or in this
case, you can write a journal response to capture your thoughts and reactions to a piece
of reading you have done. Journal writing is meant to be personal, so using
first person is probably ok. Your journal could be a mixture of both summary and
analysis, but to be a useful tool to help you practice your analytical writing skills, I
would encourage you to avoid excessive plot notes, and choose what strikes you as
important from a more literary perspective. For example, instead of a summary of the two
readings, notice one or two things the two readings have in common (or do opposite ways)
and then journal/respond to what you think the significance of those points is to
understanding the work(s) as a whole.
In being more
specific in your response you would likely use quotes, especially if you want to comment
on some literary device or the diction of the quote. Quotes usually help your response
stay more focussed. As you ask yourself, "What do I think?" What is unique about the
way this is written?" "What do I like about it?" "What questions do I have?" "What is
the point and how does the author lead me there?" "Do I agree with the point(theme)
made by the author?" If you build your own list of internal reading questions, you can
always draw on those to help you craft a journal response. Think of your journal
writing as one way for you to learn more about what you are
reading.