Sunday, February 22, 2015

What is ironic about Pip and Herbert's discussion in Chapter 41 of Great Expectations by Charles Dickens?

In Chapter XLI of Great Expectations,
there are a couple of incidences of irony.  For one, when Pip declares to Herbert that
he can no longer accept money from his benefactor now that he knows what and who he is,
Pip states that the only thing that he knows he can do to earn money is to become a
soldier.  But, Herbert suggests,


readability="8">

"You would be infinitely better at
Clariker's house, small as it is.  I am working up toward a partnership, as you
know."



Pip, then,
remarks,



Poor
fellow!  He little suspected with whose
money.



The suggestion of
Herbert's is ironic since it has been Pip himself who has procured the position for
Herbert with a monetary gift from Miss Havisham.  Now, Herbert wants to give Pip a
position.


In another instance, as Pip and Herbert both feel
aversion towards the old convict, they discuss what plans Pip can make to be free of
him.  While they consider this dilemma, ironically, the old goodness of Pip emerges in
the midst of his antipathy for Provis and he cannot simply allow Provis to "throw away"
his life if Pip rejects him.  So, they seek a plan that will be safe for
Provis.


Finally, when the old convict makes Herbert swear
to hold secret what he is about to reveal, he makes Herbert hold a Bible which,
ironically, he carries with him.  Again, there is the blending of good and evil in this
situation as there is in the first example.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment on the setting and character of "The Fall of the House of Usher."How does setting act as a character?

Excellent observation, as it identifies how the settings of Poe's stories reflect the characters of their protagonists. Whet...