Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Compare/contrast Don Quixote's and Odysseus's heroic traits and adventures.

You should be able to get many different responses to this
question in contrasting both heroes and their quests.  I would say that the primary
level of comparison between both is that they both engage in adventurous quests.
 Quixote and Odysseus face adversaries of both their own creation and out of their
control and have to essentially become classical "swashbucklers" in order to battle
through what they consider to be evil.  Quixote and Odysseus rely on their own senses of
subjectivity to appropriate the world accordingly.  Odysseus relies on his own skill and
guile to outwit his adversaries to return to Ithaca, while Quixote relies on his own
notion of chivalry and Romantic ideals to animate his spirit.  There are some distinct
differences.  The first is the presence of divinity.  Odysseus is favored by Athena and
this helps him immensely.  In contrast, I don't see Quixote as really assisted by the
power of divinity, as much as he is driven by the aforementioned spirit of romantic
ideals and the aspiration of "being a knight."  Another significant difference is that
Quixote has a sidekick in Sancho.  He comes to rely on Sancho as his assistant and
"partner in crime," so to speak.  Odysseus does not rely on anyone nor does he
essentially turn to anyone for counsel on a consistent basis.  Another difference I
would sense in both is that Odysseus is able to externalize the battle, convincing
others to fight with him against adversaries that are real and quite definable.
 Quixote's battles are more subjective in the fact that few others really understand to
what end he is fighting.  The windmills still appear windmills to everyone but
him.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment on the setting and character of "The Fall of the House of Usher."How does setting act as a character?

Excellent observation, as it identifies how the settings of Poe's stories reflect the characters of their protagonists. Whet...