Firstly, while all four of your example quotes are trope
figures of speech, only two are similes while the other two are metaphors. Similes make
figurative comparisons between two unlike things by using the words,
like or as and sometimes such
as, e.g., Love is a big expansive thing such as a
dirigible; love lies quietly in the heart as a resting rose petal;
love is glorious like a red rose. A metaphor, on the other hand,
compares two unlike things without the use of a comparative word, e.g., Love is a
dirigible; love is a resting rose petal; love is a glorious red
rose.
Secondly, the atmosphere, synonymous with mood, of
the novel is best briefly depicted through the outcome of the story. Dorian is consumed
by false theories of vanity and pleasure and destroys people's happiness, perverts and
loses his own soul, commits murder and ends in suicide. The atmosphere of The
Picture of Dorian Gray is commensurate with the dark, hedonistic,
supernaturally toned doings of Dorian Gray--as he is Gray so is the atmosphere grey as
in descending nightfall under a veil of dirty city
fog.
Thirdly, putting it all together, the best comparative
figure of speech, be it simile or metaphor, that creates an atmosphere (same as mood)
consistent with The Picture of Dorian Gray seems to me to be the
metaphor at (b): "Time being dead, dragged a hideous future from its grave." Notice
there are no comparative words, e.g., like, as, such as, so it is a
metaphor. Rationale: (1) For Dorian, time was in a very real sense dead. (2) Dorian
metaphorically dragged something hideous from its metaphoric grave. (3) Dorian had what
time would have revealed to be a hideous future ahead of him.
No comments:
Post a Comment